Sea Horse Deep Sea Fishing Customer Reviews

Name: Sea Horse Deep Sea Fishing
Brand: Sea Horse Deep Sea Fishing
Rating: 5 (35 reviews)

100% would recommend

5/5

From 35
verified reviews

Jack AI Customer Experience Snapshot

Captain Rick Rodriguez consistently delivers exceptional deep-sea fishing results, with customers regularly limiting out on mahi-mahi, blackfin tuna, wahoo, and landing prized sailfish. His expertise shines through his ability to locate fish even in challenging conditions, skillfully maneuvering the Sea Horse to productive spots when other charters return empty-handed. Rick's knowledge of tides, currents, and fish behavior helps anglers catch impressive hauls, with some trips yielding 40-50 pounds of fish to take home. Customers particularly appreciate Rick's genuine warmth and ability to connect with anglers of all ages, from excited 5-year-olds to seasoned fishermen. His honest communication about weather conditions and willingness to reschedule trips shows his commitment to ensuring great experiences. The professional crew expertly handles everything from baiting hooks to cleaning catches, while Rick shares his extensive local knowledge and creates a welcoming atmosphere. Multiple families return year after year, with many customers booking their eleventh trip and driving long distances just for the Sea Horse experience.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

Mahi-Mahi

Sailfish

Family-Friendly

Professional Crew

Fish Cleaning

Repeat Customers

Challenging Conditions

Local Knowledge

Photos from Real Customers

See all images

Three fish caught while fishing in an unknown location

School of 12 King Mackerel and Cero Mackerel fish swimming in the ocean

Fishing adventure with a large 21-inch catch

A majestic Atlantic sailfish caught by fishing

Cero mackerel and bluefish caught by fisherman in unknown location

Group of 7 people fishing in a scenic location

Anglers catching fish in unknown location

A group of 3 people fishing in an unknown location

Fisherman with large catch in unknown location

Most Reviewed Trip

Book Your Next Trip With Us

All Reviews

BRIAN GARTZ

June 29, 2025

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada - Sailfish, Tuna And More on June 29, 2025

6:30 AM - 10:30 AM

Unbelievable trip. Limited out on mahi. Captain Rick is a great guy and amazing with kids. My 14 year old met him when he was 3 and has shared the same passion ever since.

Was this helpful ?

Marcos Rojas

June 26, 2025

Trip - Extended Full Day Swordfish Adventure In Islamorada on June 26, 2025

6:30 AM - 4:30 PM

Great trip we came for Dolphin and we got Dolphin ! Captain Rick, mate Dave and Emerson did not disappoint! They all were fantastic! 5 stars , amazing experience and time . Highly recommended!!

Was this helpful ?

Coates Comstruction

June 23, 2025

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada - Sailfish, Tuna And More on June 23, 2025

6:30 AM - 10:30 AM

This is our second year in a row with Captain Rick, and I am so excited to go next year! He is awesome, a lot to fun to talk to, and we had a great time. The first mates are fantastic and we caught a lot of fish thanks to them. My 13 year old daughter came with me, and she said I would drive 24 hours just to do this for 1 day, and that proves to me how much fun it is being on captain Rick's boat/ The Sea Horse.

Was this helpful ?

Mads Hansen

June 20, 2025

Trip - Extended Full Day Swordfish Adventure In Islamorada on June 20, 2025

6:30 AM - 4:30 PM

Captain Rick got us into the fish. Hit our limit on mahi mahi, and caught a few tuna. Dave was a great first mate.

Was this helpful ?

Leeann Greer

June 18, 2025

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada - Sailfish, Tuna And More on June 18, 2025

6:30 AM - 10:30 AM

Captain Rick and David were awesome! Son’s 16th birthday deep sea fishing trip was a success! Rough seas but was still a great time and caught quite a few meals! Thank you gentlemen for a great experience!

Was this helpful ?

Terry Jameson

June 17, 2025

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada - Sailfish, Tuna And More on June 17, 2025

6:30 AM - 10:30 AM

Captain Rick and his mate David were great and took good care of us. We did a half day and they knew how to find the fish. We caught a few good Mahi and they cleaned them up and filleted them so we can have a local restaurant cook it for us. Great conversation with Captain Rick as he was friendly and welcoming. My 15year old son had a blast as this was his birthday present and my 10 year old son also had a good time. Highly recommend Sea Horse Private Charters!

Was this helpful ?

Michael Castro

June 14, 2025

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada - Sailfish, Tuna And More on June 14, 2025

6:30 AM - 10:30 AM

Awesome time the captain and crew very professional. If you want to get on fish and have good time hit up captain Rick

Was this helpful ?

Billy Borunda

June 12, 2025

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada - Sailfish, Tuna And More on June 12, 2025

6:30 AM - 10:30 AM

Best time in the keys, Fishing is on point!!

Was this helpful ?

Kelly Panczyszyn

June 10, 2025

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada - Sailfish, Tuna And More on June 10, 2025

6:30 AM - 10:30 AM

We had a great 1/2 day experience! Rick was a great captain and Dave worked his butt off baiting and taking off our fish, they both made sure we had plenty of fish to take home. Highly recommend this boat

Was this helpful ?

Kristal Stone

June 8, 2025

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada - Sailfish, Tuna And More on June 8, 2025

6:30 AM - 10:30 AM

Great day, great haul of Mahi Mahi and a blackfin tuna on Sea Horse Charter, Islamorada. 2nd time now on this charter and WILL be back again. Thank you, captain Rick and crew, for putting us on the fish.

Was this helpful ?

Stephen H

February 26, 2024

Trip - on February 26, 2024

Went out with Capt. Rick and Hunter for the second time, and once again, they delivered! True to their word, they put us on the fish, and we had an amazing time. I highly recommend them to anyone looking to catch fish and have a ton of fun!

Was this helpful ?

Joey C

October 16, 2023

Trip - on October 16, 2023

Outstanding day with Sea Horse Deep Sea Fishing! Captain Richard's expertise and the crew's hospitality made our trip incredible. A must for any fishing enthusiast!

Was this helpful ?

Islamorada Premier Fishing Charter Service

About Sea Horse Deep Sea Fishing Business Reviews

Sea Horse Deep Sea Fishing in Islamorada has been receiving raving reviews from delighted customers who have experienced the thrill of offshore and inshore fishing adventures. One customer, Sarah, expressed how the professionalism of the crew and the abundance of fish at sea made her trip an unforgettable experience. Another excited angler, David, highlighted the expertise of the guides in locating prime fishing spots, ensuring a memorable and successful day out on the water.

The consensus among customers is that Sea Horse Deep Sea Fishing provides top-notch service for both seasoned anglers and novices alike. With their passion for creating unforgettable moments on the water, it's no surprise that these customer reviews are filled with excitement and satisfaction. Whether you're seeking an adrenaline-pumping offshore excursion or a serene inshore fishing experience, Sea Horse Deep Sea Fishing has consistently proven to be a premier choice for anglers looking to make lasting memories on their Florida Keys adventure. So, if you're craving an unforgettable day of fishing along with stellar service and expert guidance, look no further than this acclaimed Islamorada deep sea charter!

Sea Horse Deep Sea Fishing Customer Reviews are provided by our guests. We focus on providing our guests with the very best experience. Our undefined reviews are from trips in Atlantic Ocean, Florida Keys, Key Largo, Marathon, Key West.